Overdue Overdue

Ep 757 - Dungeon Crawler Carl, by Matt Dinniman

Jun 29, 2026 · 2h 1m

Summary

Hosts Andrew and Craig both read Matt Dinniman’s *Dungeon Crawler Carl*, a LitRPG novel that won an internal award for being a book Andrew would likely hate. They discuss the series’ origins on Royal Road, its video game-inspired mechanics like stats and achievements, and the author’s self-publishing success. The episode critiques the book’s early "cringe" humor and overwhelming game-like notifications while analyzing its blend of fantasy storytelling and RPG elements.

Topics discussed

Mint Mobile sponsorship and intro Introduction to Dungeon Crawler Carl and the series Author Matt Dinniman's background and writing process History of LitRPG genre and Royal Road platform Defining LitRPG mechanics and comparing to games Squarespace sponsorship break Critique of the book's humor, stats, and achievements Plot summary: Carl, Donut, and the dungeon rules Analysis of characters, meta-commentary, and tone Game design parallels: exploits, cheese, and pacing Boss fights, loot, and the ending structure Final verdict, Patreon promo, and outro
Listen ad-free on Castria