Our Fake History Our Fake History

OFH Throwback - Episode #149 - Who Was the Real Stagger Lee?

Aug 18, 2026 · 1h 14m

Summary

Host Sebastian Major revisits episode 149, exploring the real-life origins of the folk legend Stagger Lee. He reveals that the myth is based on Lee Shelton, a St. Louis pimp who killed William Lyons in 1895 over a hat. The episode details the political tensions, sensational trials, and cultural significance of this true crime story. Major also shares personal anecdotes about recording the episode during a stressful period in his life.

Topics discussed

Lowe's Labor Day Savings Advertisement Introduction: Throwback to Episode 149 on Stagger Lee Personal Story: Podcasting During Pregnancy and Birth Musical Origins: From Classic Rock to Biggie Smalls The Legend of Stagger Lee: Folklore and Variations Cultural Significance: Stagger Lee as a Black Anti-Hero Ad Break and Traditional Ballad Lyrics Historical Context: Lee Shelton and St. Louis in 1895 The Incident: The Shooting of William Lyons Sprite Living Track List Advertisement Political Tensions and the First Trial The Second Trial, Conviction, and Parole Conclusion: Why the Story Became Folklore Outro: Patreon Shoutouts and Social Media
Listen ad-free on Castria