Our American Stories Our American Stories

The Story of Black Sam Bellamy, the Richest Pirate in History

Aug 20, 2026 · 7m

Summary

Ashley Lubinsky recounts the life of pirate Samuel Bellamy, who became one of history’s wealthiest before his ship, the Whydah, sank in a 1717 storm off Massachusetts. The episode details the 1984 discovery of the wreck, which holds the only documented pirate treasure, and explores Bellamy’s diverse crew and brief reign. It also covers the tragic aftermath, including the fate of survivors and the ship’s dark origins in the slave trade.

Topics discussed

Midas Tire Guarantee Advertisement Podcast Promos: Survivor Files, Hollywood Handbook, Delivering Happiness Introduction to Black Sam Bellamy and Ashley Lubinsky Discovery of the Whydah Shipwreck and Treasure The Sinking of the Whydah and Mooncussers Samuel Bellamy's Early Life and Goody Hallett Bellamy's Rise to Captaincy and Capture of the Whydah The Whydah's History and Diverse Crew Aftermath: Trials, Salvage, and Historical Legacy Outro and Subscription Call to Action Sherwin-Williams Paint Sale Advertisement Repeat Podcast Promos: Survivor Files, Hollywood Handbook, Delivering Happiness
Listen ad-free on Castria