One Strange Thing: True Paranormal Mysteries One Strange Thing: True Paranormal Mysteries

The Jack o’ Lantern

Oct 6, 2026 · 17m

Summary

Host Lauren Orton explores the origins of the jack-o'-lantern, tracing its roots from Irish turnip carving traditions to the folklore of Stingy Jack. The episode details how Jack’s trickery with the Devil led to his eternal wandering, inspiring people to create protective lanterns. It also investigates the term’s earlier usage for mysterious marsh lights, or will-o'-the-wisps, suggesting a complex blend of natural phenomena and supernatural belief.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Call Me Shelly Introduction and spooky season welcome The American tradition of jack-o'-lanterns British Isles origins: turnips and beets Purpose of carving: protection and light Sponsor: Quince Sponsor: Delete Me Sponsor: Call Me Shelly Introduction to the Stingy Jack legend Jack's first trick: trapping the Devil Jack's second trick and the deal Jack's fate: wandering in darkness Variations of the Stingy Jack story The term 'jack-o'-lantern' predates the story Will-o'-the-Wisp and ignis fatuus Evolution from ghost lights to carved gourds Dangers of following the light Intertwining folklore and changing meanings Conclusion: being scary to beat scary Outro and subscription information
Listen ad-free on Castria