Once Upon A Crime Once Upon A Crime

TRAILER: The House on New York Street, Part 2

Jul 11, 2026 · 1m

Summary

This episode concludes the Sylvia Likens case, detailing the chaotic trial where Gertrude Banaszewski, her children, and neighborhood teens all shifted blame for the horrific abuse. The hosts explore the investigation, the dramatic courtroom proceedings, and the controversial verdicts that followed. Finally, the episode reveals the long-term fates of every major figure involved, from those who served decades in prison to others who vanished into new lives.

Topics discussed

The arrest of Sylvia Likens' abusers Courtroom blame game and trial questions Fates of those involved in the case Promotion for Once Upon a Crime podcast Progressive small business insurance ad
Listen ad-free on Castria