Once Upon A Crime Once Upon A Crime

The House on New York Street: The Sylvia Likens Case, Part Two

Jul 13, 2026 · 35m

Summary

This episode concludes the two-part series on the Sylvia Likens case, detailing her brutal torture and death at the hands of Gertrude Baniszewski and neighborhood children in 1965. It covers the police investigation, the subsequent trial where multiple defendants were convicted, and the legal aftermath, including overturned convictions and eventual releases. The narrative explores the psychological factors enabling the abuse and highlights how Sylvia’s tragic death spurred mandatory child abuse reporting laws across the United States.

Topics discussed

Introduction and recap of Part 1 Sylvia's final days and death Police discovery and autopsy findings Jenny's testimony and arrests The trial and verdicts Sponsors: Whisker and Talkiatry Sentencing, appeals, and Gertrude's release Fates of the perpetrators and survivors Psychological analysis of the abuse Legacy and child protection laws Outro and podcast recommendation
Listen ad-free on Castria