Not Another D&D Podcast Not Another D&D Podcast

D&D Court: Perilous Poems and The Campout Conundrum (w/ Mike Trapp!)

Jul 24, 2026 · 1h 8m

Summary

Hosts Axford, Murphy, and Tanner, joined by guest judge Mike Trapp, adjudicate three D&D disputes in this episode of D&D Court. They rule on a player’s instant death from a puzzle potion, a camping session’s ambiguous dice rolls, and a party’s immersive Newsies musical performance. The justices debate DM responsibility, table etiquette, and the balance between player creativity and narrative control.

Topics discussed

Introduction and Courtroom Oath Case of Perilous Potions and Acme Cola Discussion on Acme Cola and Generic Sodas Analysis of Potion Puzzle and DM Intent Case of Cocked Dice in Grizzly Country Sponsors: Wayfair and Mint Mobile Case of the Newsies Musical Reenactment Case of the Blasé Devil Deal and Sarah Confession: Rolling vs Averaging Hit Dice Outro, Plugs, and Patreon Shoutouts

More from Not Another D&D Podcast

Skaldova Season 2 - Ep. 7: The Body
Nov 19, 2026
Surprise Round! - Grin and (Fozzie) Bear It
Nov 13, 2026
Skaldova Season 2 - Ep. 6: The Island in the Pond
Nov 5, 2026
Skaldova Season 2 - Ep. 5: The Wood Road (w/ Nathan Yaffe!)
Oct 29, 2026
D&D Court : Dice-Eating Dogs, Squeamish Little Freaks and The Baldur's Gate Betrayal
Oct 23, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria