No Gods No Mayors No Gods No Mayors

Peter Stuyvesant

Oct 1, 2026 · 1h 23m

Summary

Hosts Manny Lubchansky, November Kelly, and Riley Quinn discuss the 17th-century Dutch colony of New Amsterdam, focusing on the disastrous tenure of Governor Willem Kieft and his replacement, Peter Stuyvesant. The episode details the origins of the Dutch Republic, the economic motivations behind the West India Company, and the violent "Kieft’s War" sparked by attempts to tax indigenous peoples. The hosts also address a listener’s inquiry regarding a charity boxing match between two mayors, offering a humorous deal for promotion.

Topics discussed

Intro and Dutch boat banter Graham Birch's charity boxing match Dutch texting subplot and Riley update Primer on Dutch history and the 80 Years' War Dutch values, Leiden, and printing press Hudson, beavers, and New Amsterdam origins Early colony life and the West India Company Settler discontent and Native relations The Kieft War and its aftermath Kieft's governance and the council of 12 Colony foundering and need for new leadership Introduction of Peter Stuyvesant Stuyvesant's early career and Brazil Stuyvesant arrives and imposes order New Sweden and border tensions Vander Donk and the push for rights English-Dutch border negotiations The trial of Stuyvesant's conduct Anglo-Dutch war and trade conflicts Colony rights, infrastructure, and food Immigration, slavery, and social structure Religious tolerance and the Flushing Remonstrance Defeating New Sweden and Stuyvesant's legacy Cultural life and the approach of the English The 1664 surrender and Stuyvesant's death Outro and Patreon promotion
Listen ad-free on Castria