NFL Week 1 Rookie Report: Reviewing the BEST and WORST Rookie Performances
Sep 14, 2026 · 1h 21m
Summary
Trevor Siemian and Connor Rogers analyze Week 1 NFL rookies, updating their offensive and defensive Rookie of the Year odds based on a one-week sample size. They highlight standout performances from Antonio Williams, Jeremiah Love, and Francis Mauinoa, while discussing the struggles of Cam Ward and the potential of Caleb Douglas. The hosts also address fan questions regarding offensive line play and share personal anecdotes about their new NFL roles and weekend activities.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: Eczema treatment and Lincoln Tech
Show intro, LA visit, and Iowa game recap
Venice Beach and Muscle Beach banter
Methodology for Week 1 Rookie of the Year rankings
Offensive Rookie Rankings: Antonio Williams and Jeremiah Love
Francis Mauinoh and Giants offensive line performance
Sponsors: Lincoln Tech and Mohawk Mountain House
Offensive Rookie Rankings: Tate, Black, and Douglas
J.D. Price and Patriots running back dynamics
Denzel Boston and Jaguars wide receiver analysis
Defensive Rookie Rankings: Jacob Rodriguez and Arvel Reese
Sponsors: Fire TV and Orderly Meds
Defensive Rookie Rankings: Gave Bakus and David Bailey
Defensive Rookie Rankings: Hill Jr., Styles, and Reese
Trade Stukes, Cashius Howell, and edge rusher trends
Defensive Rookie Rankings: Trotter and Cassius Howell
AJ Hasey and Colts defensive performance
Caleb Downs, Cowboys game reaction, and show outro
Listen ad-free on Castria