Would You Rather: Trade Herbert, Eagles Fandom, QB or Kicker and more + Seahawks-Broncos TNF Preview
Oct 13, 2026 · 56m
Summary
Colleen Wolfe and Gregg Rosenthal recap the NFL's chaotic Week 5, starting with a "Would You Rather" segment that covers the Eagles' controversial final play, the Chargers' struggles, and the value of elite kickers. The hosts then break down the fallout from the Rams-Bills classic, including Alaric Jackson's two-game suspension for punching Bradley Chubb and Sean McVay firing kicker Harrison Meeves after a costly overtime loss. They also discuss the NFC East's collective losses, the Vikings' surprising division lead, and injury news affecting key players like Montez Sweat and Dre Greenlaw.
Topics discussed
Sponsorship ads for Wild Turkey, Ebclis, T-Mobile, and SkyRizzy
Colleen's travel mishaps and the chaotic Eagles crowd in London
Would You Rather: Watching penalties vs. explaining Eagles kickoff
Analysis of the Eagles' final drive and Dan Quinn's defense
The dominance of Brian Flores' defense and the Vikings' start
Comparing the Chargers, Dolphins, and Titans rosters and QBs
Rumors on Khalil Mack and Derwin James moving to the Bears
Would You Rather: Being a mid-tier QB or an elite kicker
The grueling schedule of NFL media and rule clarification
Philosophical debate on fan loyalty and Super Bowl experiences
Sponsorship ads for American Military University and Jace Medical
Alaric Jackson suspension and context on his legal issues
Rams special teams struggles and Sean McVay's post-game regrets
Suspensions for Dre Greenlaw and Montez Sweat
Saints QB situation and comments from Gail Benson
Injury updates for Patriots, Jaguars, and other teams
Colleen's car situation and studio logistics
Thursday Night Football preview: Seahawks vs. Broncos
Listen ad-free on Castria