Host Erin Moriarty investigates the mysterious death of Mindy Koddas, whose body was found in a Georgia forest in December 2022. The episode explores the conflicting reports of her death, including claims she had already passed away in a hospital, and the subsequent death of her husband, Nick. Moriarty delves into Mindy’s life as an aspiring podcaster and her fears of being targeted due to her husband’s former military service, questioning how she could have died twice.