My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

553 - Ohio, Let’s Say

Oct 8, 2026 · 51m

Summary

In this episode, Karen and Georgia discuss the recent DNA identification of Dr. Matthew Bukowski as a suspect in the 1982 Chicago Tylenol poisonings. They also address the "Jane Doe" movement and the ongoing discourse surrounding sexual assault accountability. The main segment features a detailed retelling of the story of Tilikum, the captive killer whale at SeaWorld who killed three people, exploring the history of orca captivity and the dangers of in-water training.

Topics discussed

Sponsorships: Klarna and Whale Fall Vintage shopping and Opa's estate sale Tylenol poisonings and Dr. Matthew Bukowski Sponsorship: Shopify Cornell student newspaper and Jane Doe allegations Podcast highlights and listener mail Other podcast recommendations Sponsorship: SimpliSafe Sponsorship: Squarespace Introduction to Tilikum and SeaWorld Orca biology and the start of the orca craze Tilikum's capture and the death of Keltie Byrne SeaWorld scrutiny and the death of Daniel Dukes Sponsorship: SimpliSafe Sponsorship: Article Blackfish documentary and previous trainer incidents The death of Dawn Brancheau Aftermath, OSHA, and SeaWorld's response Closing remarks and show recommendations Sponsorships: Klarna and 4imprint
Listen ad-free on Castria