MrCreepyPasta's Storytime MrCreepyPasta's Storytime

Jeff the Killer: Shades of Madness by K. Banning Kellum (1/?)

Sep 6, 2026 · 47m

Summary

This episode follows 13-year-old Mina Hopkins, a troubled girl obsessed with the fictional villain Jeff the Killer, as she navigates a surreal nightmare where she plans to torture her brother with a scorpion. Her former detective uncle, Dalton, tries to help her while investigating a real-life cult led by Doctor Sawyer. Author Derek Reynolds joins them to share secret journal entries from Drake Arkansas, revealing the dark truth behind the Jeff the Killer phenomenon and the cult's dangerous influence on Mina.

Topics discussed

California daily statistics intro Nina's art and the 'mind your own beeswax' incident Poisoning the teacher and trapping the brother Jeff the Killer arrives with a knife Beach wedding fantasy and philosophical banter Jeff's monologue on existence and torture Uncle Dalton intervenes and questions Jeff Nina's emotional backstory and family neglect Sponsor reads: Nissan, BMW, OxyClean, Vela California stats recap Nightmare sequence: The abyss and the scream Waking up in Dalton's apartment Dalton's reaction and internal conflict Nina recounts the dream to Dalton Medication issues and the upcoming visitor Sponsor reads: Nissan, OxyClean, Vela Sunrise antics and neighbor complaints Dalton's past as a cop and current risks Life in the apartment and Nina's impact Sponsor reads: Nissan, BMW, OxyClean, Vela Derek Reynolds arrives and meets Nina Nina's knowledge of Lacey and the plan Derek shares details on Jane and Dr. Sawyer Reading from Drake Arkansas's secret journal Patreon shoutouts and credits Sponsor reads: Staples, Just Food, Sensodyne
Listen ad-free on Castria