We're Going In (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
Jul 27, 2026 · 31m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 2010 disappearance of Kathy Goebel in West Virginia, who was last seen at her boyfriend’s apartment before vanishing. Detective Brian Carper investigates the case, questioning suspects including Kathy’s boyfriend, ex-husband, and a coworker’s daughter, but the case goes cold for two years. In 2012, heavy rains unearth Kathy’s dismembered body in a backyard, leading to the arrest of Charles March, a shoe salesman who had stalked and killed her after she rejected his advances.
Topics discussed
Cold open: The backyard discovery
Sponsors: Progressive and Mint Mobile
Kathy Goble and her affair with Dr. Harry King
Kathy's relationship with Fred Farrell
The confrontation with Jessica Fisher at work
Kathy leaves work and calls Fred
Kathy's final phone call to Laura
Jason McCartney discovers his mom is missing
Sponsors: Progressive, Mint, and Burlington
Detective Carper interrogates Fred Farrell
Investigating David McCartney and the call records
Laura Henderson reveals the 'we' comment
Kathy's SUV found abandoned on the highway
Sponsors: Progressive and Burlington
Revisiting the store and questioning Harry King
Interrogating Jessica Fisher and the polygraph
Dead ends: Lack of forensic evidence
The body is unearthed by floodwaters
Reconstruction of the murder and Charles March's arrest
Credits, outro, and book promotion
More from MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
Listen ad-free on Castria