Open Door Policy (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
Summary
This episode details the 2009 murder of Laguna Beach event planner Damon Nicholson, who was beaten to death in his apartment. Detective Larry Bamer investigates the crime, navigating contradictory clues like a missing phone and an open door that suggest both robbery and personal involvement. After interviewing suspects involved in Damon’s anonymous sex parties, DNA evidence from a trash can liner leads to 19-year-old Matthew Dragna. Dragna and his accomplice are convicted of manslaughter and burglary after planning the attack to rob Damon, resulting in lengthy prison sentences.
Topics discussed
Introduction: The college student and campus police
Sponsor: Progressive Insurance and Appliance Breakdowns
Damon's life in Laguna Beach and his social circle
The night of the murder: Damon's work and the open door
Lindsay Scott discovers the body and calls 911
Detective Bammer arrives at the crime scene
Forensic analysis: No forced entry and missing items
Sponsor: Omaha Steaks and Southern New Hampshire University
Sponsor: Wayfair and the search for the missing phone
Reviewing the autopsy and DNA evidence from the trash
The building custodian returns Damon's cell phone
Interviewing Ethan: The suspicious hand injury
Interviewing Todd: The anonymous group sex routine
Narrowing the suspect pool and identifying Alan Caulfield
Phone interview with Alan Caulfield
Sponsor: Hungry Root and SimplSafe
Confronting Alan at his college classroom
Re-evaluating suspects: Todd, Ethan, and the DNA wait
The DNA match and the final theory of the crime
Reconstruction: The killer's entry and the attack
The arrest, trial, and sentencing of the killers
Credits and subscription information
Sponsor: Angie and financial advice
Listen ad-free on Castria