Fan Favorite - "Holiday Fear"
Oct 23, 2026 · 40m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 2003 murders of Rick and Susie Wamsley in Texas, who were shot and stabbed by their son Andrew, his girlfriend Chelsea, and Chelsea’s friend Susanna. The trio killed the couple to inherit a $1.5 million estate, with Susanna acting as the primary shooter after a previous failed attempt. The investigation was complicated by the victims’ other children, Sarah and Andrew, who were initially prime suspects due to financial motives and lack of alibis.
Topics discussed
Introduction and the filthy kitchen clue
Susie Wamsley's Christmas preparations
Family tensions and Andrew's absence
The quiet evening before the murders
The silent 911 call and police arrival
Discovery of the bodies and initial scene
Detectives analyze the chaotic crime scene
Victim analysis and the hair in Rick's hand
Neighbor testimony and suspect profiling
Interviewing Andrew Wamsley
Interviewing Sarah and the ex-husband lead
Financial motives and ruling out the children
Interrogating Todd Cleveland
Visiting Chelsea's home and the dirty kitchen
DNA collection and waiting for results
Reconstruction of the murder night
The killer revealed and convictions
Credits and podcast promotion
More from MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
Listen ad-free on Castria