Born Together
Oct 22, 2026 · 25m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode recounts the 1962 case of identical twins Bobby and Betty Eller, whose extreme codependency led to involuntary psychiatric hospitalization. After doctors forcibly separated the sisters into different wards, both died within minutes of each other with no apparent medical cause. The story highlights the baffling mystery surrounding their deaths, noting that their bodies were positioned on their beds to face one another across the hospital, fueling theories of a supernatural bond.
Topics discussed
Introduction: A bizarre medical and supernatural mystery
Bobby and Betty move to Winston-Salem for factory jobs
The twins' intense bond and synchronized behaviors
Bobby quits and returns home, Betty stays away
Bobby's decline and dependence on Betty's visits
Betty quits and returns home to live with Bobby
Extreme codependency and refusal to eat
Diagnosis of schizophrenia and failed treatment
Repeated hospitalizations and the decision to separate
Forced separation and the mysterious deaths
Investigation finds no cause of death
The supernatural theory and the position of the bodies
Credits and podcast outro
More from MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
Listen ad-free on Castria