Rumor Has It (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
Nov 2, 2026 · 29m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 2012 murder of Betsy Ball, a farm owner in rural Ohio, who was kidnapped, strangled, and mutilated by her longtime farmhand, Lee Hawkins. The narrative follows Detective Chris Gill as he investigates the crime, initially suspecting Betsy’s husband David before alibis shift focus to Hawkins, who had a documented fascination with the BTK serial killer. Hawkins is ultimately convicted of aggravated murder and sentenced to life in prison after his wife recanted her false alibi.
Topics discussed
Cold open: The farmer and the intruder
Sponsors: SNHU and Progressive Insurance
Betsy Ball notices a stranger on her farm
The visitor identifies himself as Sean Petri
Betsy's phone call and the headlights
David returns to find Betsy missing
Detective Gill investigates the garage scene
Sponsors: NoCoBoost, Progressive, Southwest
Discovery of Betsy's body in the field
Investigating David's alibi at the power plant
Interviewing farmhand Lee Hawkins
Sponsors: YouTube Premium and Southwest
Interrogating Sean Petri, the last witness
Mechanic overhears suspect details at shop
Reconstruction of the murder and kidnapping
The killer revealed: Lee Hawkins and BTK
Credits, disclaimer, and final sponsors
More from MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
Listen ad-free on Castria