Moncrieff Moncrieff

So You Think You’re an Adult: I want my old boyfriend back!

Oct 15, 2026 · 22m

Summary

Hosts Barbara Scully and Declan Buckley discuss whether a 40-year-old woman should lie about her age on dating apps to bypass filters, concluding that while it may help initially, honesty is ultimately necessary. They also address a listener’s dilemma about coming out to her rural family, emphasizing that while it requires courage, living authentically is essential for long-term happiness and self-acceptance.

Topics discussed

Listener asks about lying about age on dating apps Debate on honesty vs. gaming the algorithm Discussion on age filters and societal judgments The psychological impact of dating app profiles Listener reactions and personal anecdotes on age Debate on 'ripeness' and biological age concerns Final verdict on age deception and plan B New question: Coming out to rural family The energy cost of maintaining a secret identity Contextualizing Ireland's progress and global setbacks Personal experience with coming out and resilience The burden of educating others on minority experiences Choosing battles and managing public affection The daily reality of 'coming out' in public Confidence vs. control in managing two lives Listener tips and closing remarks
Listen ad-free on Castria