I Left My Fiancé, My Church and My Shame
Summary
Comedian Taylor Tomlison discusses her memoir, "Actually Neverind," and the decision to end her engagement at 25. She reflects on how her religious upbringing and fear of dying young, mirroring her mother’s age at death, created a rigid life timeline. Tomlison explores her journey toward self-acceptance, including coming out as bisexual and navigating mental health struggles that previously made her relationship feel like a necessary "mood stabilizer." The episode highlights her current perspective on love, career, and finding hope through comedy while letting go of societal expectations.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Instagram teen account safety features
Intro: Host welcome and NYT subscription promo
Introduction to Taylor Tomlinson and her life timeline
Growing up in a religious family and church comedy
Meeting her fiancé and the speed of the relationship
The pressure of the 'timeline' and family expectations
Defining 'clean' comedy and seeking family approval
The proposal in the grandparents' walnut orchard
Initial certainty and hidden doubts about the future
Acknowledging queerness and the fiancé's supportive response
Reading her late mother's journals and marriage doubts
Comparing her timeline to her mother's college years
Fear of dying at 34 and the Netflix special offer
Sponsors: Apple Card and Southern New Hampshire University
Mental health struggles and using the relationship as a crutch
The breakup and the aftermath of guilt and therapy
Finding the right medication and accepting the loss
Coming out as bisexual and overcoming sexual guilt
Dating women and finding comfort in shared religious backgrounds
Sponsors: Apple Card, Instagram, and SNHU
Navigating singlehood and comparing to siblings' relationships
Envisioning the future and the power of laughter
Credits and outro
Sponsor: Merit Beauty morning routine
Listen ad-free on Castria