Missing & Murdered: Finding Cleo Missing & Murdered: Finding Cleo

S2 Episode 10: Cleo’s letters

Apr 2, 2018 · 55m

Summary

This episode investigates the 1978 death of 13-year-old Cleo Madonia, a Plains Cree girl adopted from Saskatchewan to New Jersey. Through Cleo’s letters, police reports, and interviews with her teachers and family, the story reveals her deep distress over being separated from her Indigenous family and her relationship with an older man named Barry. The narrative explores the circumstances of her suicide, including her final attempts to return to Canada, and concludes with her sister visiting Cleo’s grave to find closure and honor her memory.

Topics discussed

Episode intro and title card Police report: Discovery of the body Cleo's letters to best friend Lori Family life and school struggles Meeting Barry and planning a date Relationship dynamics and final notes Interviews: Mother and teacher on the day of death Timeline reconstruction and brother's account Investigating Barry Arnold and the note Barry's police interview and later charges Case closure and Cleo's background Teacher's reflection and unanswered questions Sister's visit to the grave and legacy Credits and closing statement

More from Missing & Murdered: Finding Cleo

The kid who confronted his abuser at residential school (via See You in Court)
Sep 29, 2026
S2 Episode 9: Reunion
Mar 27, 2018
Listen ad-free on Castria