Marketplace All-in-One Marketplace All-in-One

Is money ruining fan fiction?

Sep 24, 2026 · 25m

Summary

Host Rima Reyes explores the commercialization of fanfiction with cultural commentator Josh Laura and journalist Elizabeth Minkle. They discuss how stories from platforms like Archive of Our Own are becoming bestsellers, citing examples like 50 Shades of Gray and The Love Hypothesis. The conversation covers the shift from a gift economy to a profit-driven industry, including the controversial practice of "filing off serial numbers" and the rise of paid fan binding. The episode also features a fun game guessing the number of fanfics for various character pairings.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Odu business software Promo: Rethinking podcast Intro: Fanfiction to bestsellers Guest introductions Elizabeth Minkle's fanfiction origin story Josh Laura's early fandom experiences Host perspective on fanfiction economics History: Print zines and the gift economy 50 Shades of Gray and 'filing off serial numbers' Fandom reactions to commercialization Community resentment and 'pull to publish' Sponsor and promo break Fan binding: Physical books and influencers The Draco/Hermione bind controversy Publishing industry and copyright gray areas Future of fanfiction and creative integrity Game: Guessing fanfiction pairings Outro and credits
Listen ad-free on Castria