305: She Was Brutally Attacked In Front of Her Child... Her Killer Was Free For Years
Jul 27, 2026 · 1h 26m
Summary
This episode of Lights Out examines the 1992 murder of Rachel Nickell and the subsequent wrongful accusation of Colin Stagg. The hosts discuss how police misconduct and tunnel vision allowed the real killer, serial rapist Robert Knapper, to remain at large. They highlight the tragic failure to connect Knapper’s prior assaults to the murders, which led to the deaths of Samantha Bissette and her daughter.
Topics discussed
Introduction and overview of the Rachel Nickell case
Rachel Nickell's life and the day of her murder
Initial investigation and focus on Colin Stagg
Operation Edzel: The honey trap to frame Colin
The murder of Samantha Bissette and Jasmine Cann
Profile of the real killer, Robert Napper
Impact on Andre and Alex and media intrusion
Police negligence and failure to catch Napper
DNA breakthrough and arrest of Robert Napper
Napper's trial, conviction, and police misconduct
Alex's journey of forgiveness and healing
Listen ad-free on Castria