168 | Why Kylian Mbappe Shouldn't Win The Ballon D'Or
Oct 20, 2026 · 1h 0m
More Sports podcasts
Summary
Hosted by Rory Smith, Jonathan Wilson, and James Horncastle, this episode debates the 2025 Ballon d'Or winner, weighing contenders like Harry Kane, Rodri, and Lamine Yamal against the backdrop of the recent World Cup. The hosts analyze whether the award should prioritize individual moments or collective team success, noting the heavy influence of PSG players and the growing trend of players lobbying for votes.
Topics discussed
Intro: Ballon d'Or debate and guest introductions
Sponsorship segments for Rethinking and ZipRecruiter
Anecdotes from Sunderland's European match in L'Oreal
Announcement of upcoming live shows in Leeds and London
Miguel's Argentina trip and the 2018 Super Clásico chaos
The case for Lionel Messi and Rodri as Ballon d'Or winners
Messi's historical dominance and the Messi vs Ronaldo parallel
Defining the award: individual brilliance vs team success
Historical precedents and the role of international tournaments
Spain's World Cup performance and the Rodri vs Yamal debate
Harry Kane's goal stats and the case for Lamine Yamal
The lack of a standout candidate and the 'best of the best' dilemma
Unfairness to non-World Cup players and the 1986 precedent
Historical context: 1986, 2002, and the evolution of voting criteria
The influence of social media consciousness and team balance
SC Libero membership plug and Mint Mobile/Odoo ads
Ballon d'Or history quiz: British players and non-European winners
Player lobbying campaigns and the role of agents and media
The integrity of voters and the commercialization of player brands
Kylian Mbappe's candidacy, Real Madrid struggles, and Nike deal
Goal-scoring metrics vs midfielders and the 'era of eclipse'
Predictions for the winner and the 'Dead Man's Shoes' effect
Outro and Extra Time segment promotion
More from Libero
Listen ad-free on Castria