Buchkritik: "Aus anderem Holz" von Guiliano Musio
Summary
Stefan Mesch reviews Giuliano Musio's novel *Aus anderem Holz*, a Swiss entry on the German Book Prize longlist. The story reimagines Pinocchio as a wooden boy replacing a deceased human son, exploring themes of replacement and imposter syndrome in a 1989 Italian village. Mesch praises the book's originality and handling of historical context but criticizes its chaotic structure and underdeveloped female characters. He concludes that while the novel is a cult favorite for specific readers, it may not appeal to a broad audience due to its sperrig beginning and complex narrative.
Topics discussed
Introduction to Giuliano Musio's novel and its Book Prize nomination
Plot summary: Pino, a wooden puppet, replaces a deceased son
The concept of the 'Replacement Goldfish' and literary parallels
The book as a metaphor for imposter syndrome and inadequacy
Historical context: 1989, Catholicism, and LGBTQ+ themes
Balancing fantastical metaphors with realistic social exclusion
Why the story is set in Italy and its accessible local style
Assessment of the novel's chances on the Shortlist and its flaws
The author's polarizing style and previous work 'Wirbellos'
Final verdict: A cult author for a specific audience
Book details and closing remarks
Listen ad-free on Castria