Killer Stories with Harvey Guillén Killer Stories with Harvey Guillén

The Missing Candy Heiress and the Chicago Horse Mafia

Jun 29, 2026 ยท 34m

Topics discussed

Introduction: The difficulty of investigating disappearances Helen Brack's life: From coal miner's daughter to candy heiress The last known sighting at the Mayo Clinic gift shop Jack Matlick's account and the red flags in his story Sponsor reads: Chime, Talkiatry, and WSS Police refusal to file report and the burning of private papers Forensic evidence disproving Jack's timeline and actions The lawyer's refusal to release Helen's will Sponsor reads: Sally and Choice Hotels The will's contents and Helen's legal death Richard Bailey and the Chicago Horse Mafia scandal Stephen Miller's investigation and Joe Plemons' confession Richard Bailey's 1994 trial and conviction for fraud 2005 revelations: Silas Jane's role and the murder plot Conclusion: The unsolved nature of Helen's death
Listen ad-free on Castria