Chapter 12: Probable Cause
Summary
Host Michael Connolly interviews two veteran judges to assess whether the evidence against Marvin Margolis meets legal standards for probable cause and conviction in the Black Dahlia and Zodiac cases. Both jurists conclude the circumstantial evidence, including code-breaking and handwriting analysis, is overwhelming and sufficient for trial. The episode also addresses potential defense strategies, the credibility of lead investigator Alex Babber, and the strategic selection of charges for prosecution.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: Brie Pasta, North Myrtle Beach, and Underdog
Introduction: Judges review Black Dahlia and Zodiac evidence
Judge Trott confirms overwhelming probable cause
Key evidence: Code, handwriting, and the Elizabeth sketch
Defense strategies and the Glasgow smile controversy
The power of circumstantial evidence and suspect elimination
Prosecutorial strategy: Handling Alex Babber as a witness
Judge Trott's folk music history and intro to Judge Wick
Judge Wick affirms case strength and potential charges
Legal standards for circumstantial evidence and tunnel vision
Charging decisions and the Sam Little serial killer analogy
Alex Babber's testimony potential and episode conclusion
Listen ad-free on Castria