I'll Have Another: 'Oreogate' & Gentle Parenting with Jessica Tarlov
Oct 30, 2026 · 25m
Summary
Kennedy and co-host Jessica Tarlov discuss the viral "Oreo Gate" incident, where a mother’s attempt to ban Oreos from a kindergarten class sparked a backlash from other parents. The conversation expands to critique "gentle parenting" trends, share anecdotes about parental boundaries and discipline, and compare the social dynamics of public versus private school communities.
Topics discussed
Introduction and the Oreo Gate premise
The story of Michelle and the Oreo police
Debating the justification of withholding treats
Gentle parenting vs. setting boundaries
Stories of difficult parents and discipline
Parental anxiety and screen time guilt
Lack of transparency and the Snapchat incident
Sponsorship break
Public vs. private school dynamics and wealth
Lunch packing struggles and closing remarks
Listen ad-free on Castria