Jay'sAnalysis Jay'sAnalysis

Jay Dyer with Sam Shamoun: Why is Calvinism WRONG!

Oct 2, 2026 · 3h 5m

Summary

The speaker, a former Calvinist, critiques the TULIP doctrine by arguing it stems from a flawed "order of theology" that prioritizes soteriology over Trinitarian and Christological foundations. He contends that Calvinism’s views on total depravity and monergism contradict the nuanced distinctions between nature and person established in the early ecumenical councils, particularly the Fifth and Sixth. The episode explains how these errors lead to a Nestorian ecclesiology and a limited atonement that ignores the cosmic scope of Christ’s recapitulation.

Listen ad-free on Castria