Debating the American Role in the Middle East
Summary
Host Dana Elkherd analyzes three recent policy essays debating the status of US hegemony in the Middle East following the Iran war. She critiques the Washington-centric focus of these arguments, arguing that the region’s crisis stems from decades of US-backed authoritarianism rather than a simple shift in power dynamics. Elkherd highlights how the failure of the "liberal order" has eroded public trust, as evidenced by declining support for US mediation in Arab polls. The episode concludes by urging a move away from waiting for US policy changes toward building independent international acco…
Topics discussed
Sponsorships and show introduction
Episode overview: US role in the Middle East
Critique of 'order is over' narrative
Analysis of Gaus's argument on structural continuity
Sponsor break: Airtasker
Promotional segments for other iHeart shows
Lynch's argument: The death of the post-1991 order
Critique of US-centric theory of change
Historical analogies and regional agency
Cook's analysis: The Mecca Agreement and new blocks
Authoritarian nature of the new regional coalition
Sponsor breaks and promotional segments
Synthesis of the three scholarly perspectives
Host's 2023 thesis: Palestine as a gateway to dissent
Long-term decline of US credibility in the region
Prescriptions: Moving beyond Washington-centric repair
Closing sponsorships and sign-off
Listen ad-free on Castria