It Could Happen Here It Could Happen Here

Anarchists and the Great War with Andrew

Sep 1, 2026 · 26m

Summary

Host Andrew Sage and guest Mia Wog examine the 1914 anarchist split over World War I, contrasting Errico Malatesta’s strict internationalism with Peter Kropotkin’s support for the Allies. They analyze the Manifesto of the 16 and the Manifesto of the 35, debating whether siding with a "lesser evil" state betrays revolutionary principles. The episode connects this historical rift to modern geopolitical conflicts and the enduring challenge of maintaining class solidarity against imperialist war.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: TNA Wrestling, LingoKids, Vital Proteins, OnDeck Introduction: Anarchist split over WWI and international solidarity WWI Origins: Imperial rivalry and the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand Kropotkin's Pro-Allied Stance: Anti-German sentiment and historical context Malatesta's Critique: Rejection of lesser evilism and state support Sponsors: TNA Wrestling, LingoKids, Addyi, OnDeck Manifesto of the 35: Anarchist International's anti-war principles Manifesto of the 16: Kropotkin's defense and Malatesta's rebuttal Sponsors: TNA Wrestling, LingoKids, Addyi, OnDeck Post-War Impact: Russian Revolution and anarchist experiments Analysis: Evaluating Kropotkin's position and socialist movement failure Conclusion: Modern relevance, international solidarity, and final sponsors
Listen ad-free on Castria