In The Dark In The Dark

The Journey, Episode 1: Gifts

Sep 15, 2026 · 59m

Summary

Investigative reporter Ava Kaufman details the story of Kayla Elliott, a surrogate who discovered she was one of many women carrying children for a couple in Arcadia, California. The couple, who operated a fraudulent agency, allegedly abused their numerous children, leading to an FBI investigation and the removal of 21 infants into foster care. The episode explores the legal and emotional complexities faced by the surrogates, who are legally barred from claiming custody despite their concerns for the babies' safety.

Topics discussed

Introduction and subscription appeal Kayla Elliott's background and initial surrogacy Discovery of the scheme and police involvement Reporter Ava Kaufman meets Kayla in LA Kayla's family situation and finding the agency Meeting the intended parents and embryo transfer Kayla's concerns about lack of contact The embryo transfer day and gifts Challenges of surrogacy and medical issues Labor and birth without the parents present First meeting with Sylvia and the baby Postpartum feelings and request for another surrogacy Connecting with other surrogates and suspicions Fear of child selling and legal risks Surrogates finding each other and evidence of fraud Sylvia's call revealing jail time and confusion Child welfare investigation and foster care Emotional toll and other pending pregnancies Stacy King's story and initial panic Stacy contacts authorities and legal questions Surrogates organizing and preparing for birth Sylvia's charm offensive and recorded calls Police affidavit reveals abuse and unlicensed daycare Stacy's decision to protect the baby Critique of the agency and closing remarks Credits and call to action
Listen ad-free on Castria