Episode 4: One Star Reviews
Jun 15, 2026 · 38m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates how Amazon continued selling sodium nitrite, a lethal chemical, despite knowing it was used for suicide, prompting a lawsuit by attorney Carrie Goldberg. The narrative traces the chemical’s popularity to Philip Nitschke, who promoted it in his organization’s handbook after Australia’s euthanasia laws were overturned. The story highlights the failures of online platforms and the persistent, evolving nature of suicide forums, concluding that arresting individual sellers like Kenneth Law is merely a symptom of a larger systemic issue.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Citizens Bank cash bonus offer
Content warning regarding suicide
Carrie Goldberg's near-suicide on the Aran Islands
Law firm mission: fighting online harassment and tech platforms
Discovery of sodium nitrite suicide forum and Amazon sales
Amazon search results and one-star reviews
Ruth Scott's case and initial demand letter to Amazon
Amazon's legal defense and continued sales to minors
Amazon's internal policies and failure to remove product
Meredith Mitchell's struggle to get Amazon to act
Congressional pressure and comparison to other platforms
Sales data spike and lack of household use
Amazon's response and current lawsuit status
Notifying independent vendors and Kenneth Law's evasion
Market demand and the origin of the method
Philip Nitschke and the first legal euthanasia case
Evolution of Nitschke's philosophy and Exit International
Introduction of sodium nitrite as a suicide method
Restrictions, Kenneth Law's role, and police checks
The persistence of online suicide communities
Episode credits and resources
More from Hunting the Suicide Salesman
Listen ad-free on Castria