How Did This Get Made? How Did This Get Made?

Joyful Noise w/ Fred Stoller (Classic)

Sep 8, 2026 · 58m

Summary

Paul Shear, June Diane Raphael, and Jason Mantzoukas discuss the 2012 film *Joyful Noise*, featuring Dolly Parton and Queen Latifa. They critique the movie’s disjointed plot, which mixes a teen romance, a small-town depression, and a gospel choir competition with nonsensical dark humor. The hosts highlight specific flaws, such as the bad lip-syncing, the unexplained death of a character, and the awkward handling of Asperger’s syndrome. They also analyze the film’s chaotic structure, comparing it to a poorly edited documentary that fails to connect its numerous subplots.

Topics discussed

Nissan Frontier truck commercial Disney Plus and ESPN college football promo Introduction to the movie Joyful Noise Guest introduction: Fred Stoller Discussion of musical numbers and casting Critique of Dolly Parton's role and wealth The concept of competitive religious music Plot flaw regarding Queen Latifa's husband Opening scene and Christopher Walken's heart attack The memorial service and sudden replacement Power struggle between Dolly and Queen Latifa The choir's inability to support both stars The young love story subplot The grandson's arrival and Dolly's shotgun Dolly's cavalier attitude and bad instincts Subplots about the recession and hardware store The hardware store closure and montage Mister Sue and the town's economic state Black humor and the young couple's relationship Mister Sue's death and the tray meals Queen Latifa's worry about being a black widow Mint Mobile 5G network commercial Quince clothing and home goods commercial Babbel language learning app commercial Discussion on live singing vs. tracks Bad lip syncing in the movie The Asperger's character and sunglasses The piano scene and one-hit wonders Auditioning for the Asperger's role The mysterious hip-hop character The quarry scene and pronunciation Singing at the quarry and the bad guy Randy's backstory and love for Olivia Randy's musical talent and intentions The unexplained conflict between Dolly and daughter Night scenes and the relationship timeline The club scene and Step Up comparison The dance floor scene and lack of progression Man in the Mirror and convincing Queen Latifa The quarry scene as a beach setting The fight scene and light punches The guitar kid and fronting in the choir Showcasing the hard-working mother The joke about the tough life The two jobs and choir director firing The tissue of shit in the locker Audible audiobook commercial YouTube Premium commercial The documentary filmmaker subplot The husband's camcorder footage Flashbacks and the timeline ambiguity The husband's return and war presumption The army base and security guard role The kidnapping and lack of cell phones The police response and logic gaps Queen Latifa's belief about Walter The complexity of the husband character The husband's blase goodbye and SEAL team The letter writing and handwriting mimicry Christopher Walken's duet with a dead man The cornfield dance and emotional duet The ghost version of the song The competition and the detective subplot The Detroit group and the competition The James Brown-esque choir leader Scab gospel singers and hired professionals Redemption and the third act falling apart The nurse monologue and jealousy The audition monologue and mother's jealousy The single mother story and Asperger's son The elevator bank and random hotel set The feeble food fight and diva actresses The plastic surgery and wealth disparity Christopher Walken's legacy and Dolly's future The woman who killed Mister Sue The bathroom scene and murder presumption High blood pressure and the bacon The window view and impossible geography The bus ride and production budget The final performance and combining worlds The failure and the win Five-star Amazon reviews The DVD purchase and cousin's husband Recommendation and final thoughts Podcast outro and subscription request Zepbound weight loss injection commercial Temper Pedic mattress commercial

More from How Did This Get Made?

Last Looks: Meet the Deedles
Nov 20, 2026
Designed to Kill LIVE! (Classic)
Nov 17, 2026
Meet the Deedles
Nov 13, 2026
Streets of Fire LIVE! w/ Rachel Bloom & Jessica St. Clair (Classic)
Nov 10, 2026
Last Looks: Seed of Chucky
Nov 6, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria