Holy Uncertain Holy Uncertain

Can Doubt Help Us Grow? | Meredith Miller

Jun 19, 2026 · 1h 5m

Summary

Hosts Chris McLeod and Lauren Ranzino welcome pastor Meredith Miller to explore doubt as a healthy, developmental stage of faith rather than a sign of weakness. Miller critiques rigid "foundationalist" belief systems, advocating instead for a flexible "web" of faith anchored in God’s character rather than perfect doctrine. The discussion highlights how embracing uncertainty and questioning can lead to a more resilient, secure relationship with God.

Topics discussed

Intro: The anxiety of doubt and the fallacy of foundationalism Hosts discuss the shame of questioning faith and introduce guest Meredith Miller on developmental stages: Foreclosure and Moratorium Personal histories: Growing up with doubt vs. rigid faith systems The cultural shift toward prescriptive parenting and sin management Faith as a web vs. a tower: Flexibility and resilience in belief The foundation is a person, not a building: Biblical metaphors Navigating faith collapse: Giving yourself space and grace Reading the Bible with better guides: Context and cultural differences The role of scholarship and engaging with difficult texts Attachment styles in faith: Moving from anxiety to trust Reframing biblical narratives: God as the main character Parenting for faith: Creating safe spaces for dialogue Resources for adults: The Reweaving devotional The future of American evangelicalism and local church work Closing thoughts: The benefits of doubt and trusting God's stability
Listen ad-free on Castria