Saturday Matinee: Haunted American History
Oct 31, 2026 · 31m
More History podcasts
Summary
Host Christopher Feinstein explores the ghost stories of Gettysburg, contrasting verified historical events with folklore like the "Devil's Den" sharpshooter and the Saks Covered Bridge hanging. The episode details the 1863 battle's human cost through specific regimental accounts and examines the origins of local legends, including the Pennsylvania Hall elevator incident. It concludes by analyzing how these supernatural narratives serve as a way for visitors to process the overwhelming scale of Civil War casualties.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Progressive Insurance
Introduction: The deadliest ground in American history
Gettysburg's reputation for ghosts and hauntings
Sponsor: Progressive Insurance
Sponsor: Hotels.com
Sponsor: CVS Holiday Shopping
Sponsor: BMW Certified Pre-Owned
The Gettysburg College elevator ghost story
Show intro: Haunted American History
Strategic context: Lee's invasion and Meade's command
July 1st: Buford's cavalry and the initial fighting
Key battlefield locations and their origins
Pickett's Charge and the scale of casualties
Alonzo Cushing and the defense of Little Round Top
The Wheatfield and the final assault on the Union line
The retreat and the 17-mile wagon train of wounded
The aftermath: Dead horses and resurfacing bones
Gettysburg as a cemetery: Mass graves and memory
Sponsor: Progressive Insurance
Sponsor: Hotels.com
Sponsor: CVS Holiday Shopping
Sponsor: BMW Certified Pre-Owned
Devil's Den: History and pre-war folklore
The battle at Devil's Den and the 'Devil' snake legend
Early sightings and the naming of Devil's Den
Photographers moving bodies for better compositions
Modern ghost stories: Failing cameras and fogged photos
The ragged Confederate soldier apparition
Analysis: How folklore evolves and persists
The Old Stone Bridge: Historical significance
The phantom horse and hoofbeats on the bridge
Debunking the bridge ghost: Fake lore and aesthetics
The Farnsworth House: History and Lincoln's procession
Farnsworth House ghost tours and Victorian seances
Gettysburg College as a field hospital
Colonel Walre Patton and the college's haunted legacy
Modern reports of remains and the 2003 elevator incident
Other campus hauntings: Football player and signalman
Sponsor: Progressive Insurance
Sponsor: Hotels.com
Sponsor: CVS Holiday Shopping
Sponsor: BMW Certified Pre-Owned
The reality of Gettysburg: Maintenance and tourism
The rise of ghost tours and their impact on history
Why we tell stories instead of processing statistics
Conclusion: The human cost and the enduring ground
Outro and show credits
Sponsor: Hotels.com
Sponsor: BMW Certified Pre-Owned
More from History Daily
Listen ad-free on Castria