Hidden History with Dr. Harini Bhat Hidden History with Dr. Harini Bhat

HAUNTED TAKEOVER: The First 48: Brothers Down

Oct 29, 2026 · 41m

Summary

This episode of "The First 48" details the investigation into the double homicide of brothers Keith and Glenn Williams, who were shot outside a Tulsa dialysis center. Detectives initially suspect a robbery or dispute with an employee, Jamila, but later identify Andre L. Smith as the killer after matching a gun from a separate shooting. Smith is convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison, providing closure to the victims' families.

Topics discussed

Intro and promotion of What the Fact Case overview: Brothers Down in Tulsa 911 call and initial dispatch Episode intro and sponsor read Sponsor: Jenny Bird jewelry Sponsor: Sleep product and Bombas Detective Kennedy arrives at the scene Victim identification: Keith Williams Scene evidence: shell casings found Detective Calhoun contacts Mary Williams Identifying second victim via tattoo Detective's reflection on the call Early investigation: unknown motive Interview with 911 caller Jamila Jamila describes suspicious SUV Jamila's account of the shooting Follow-up call to victims' wives Sponsor: Bombas socks Sponsor: Crimes of Reddit podcast Detective Calhoun's follow-up call Detective's emotional reaction New lead: witness saw suspect vehicle Return to scene and witness interview Detective Calhoun re-interviews Jamila Investigation theories: hit vs robbery Jamila's second interview with attorney Detectives' assessment of Jamila Detective's internal monologue Two weeks later: new lead from Watkins Suspect identified: Andre L. Smith Linking Smith to Incredible Pizza shooting Smith's girlfriend arrested and released Vigil for Glenn Williams' family Charges dropped against girlfriend Sponsor: ixl learning platform Sponsor: HomeServe repairs Sponsor: Government That Doesn't Suck Locating Smith's girlfriend for interview Interview with Smith's girlfriend begins Girlfriend confirms presence at murder Girlfriend describes the shooting Girlfriend claims Smith shot her Detectives' reaction to interview Interview with Andre Smith begins Smith denies involvement in murder Ballistics evidence presented to Smith Smith refuses DNA sample Detectives' frustration with Smith Charges dismissed and family notified Calling victims' families with update Mary Williams' reflection seven months later Episode outro and next week preview Return to What the Fact and sponsor What the Fact intro and history fact Sponsor: Nissan Rogue

More from Hidden History with Dr. Harini Bhat

Sleep Paralysis & the Hat Man: The Internet's Most Terrifying Nightmare with Alexis Linkletter of Crimes of Reddit
Nov 16, 2026
Gloria Ramirez: The Science and Mystery Behind "The Toxic Lady"
Nov 9, 2026
The Moon Landing: Why Millions Believe It Was Fake
Nov 2, 2026
The Enfield Poltergeist with Josh Nannochio of What Lurks Beneath
Oct 26, 2026
The Jersey Devil: America's Oldest Monster Explained
Oct 19, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria