HAUNTED TAKEOVER: The First 48: Brothers Down
Oct 29, 2026 · 41m
More History podcasts · More Science podcasts
Summary
This episode of "The First 48" details the investigation into the double homicide of brothers Keith and Glenn Williams, who were shot outside a Tulsa dialysis center. Detectives initially suspect a robbery or dispute with an employee, Jamila, but later identify Andre L. Smith as the killer after matching a gun from a separate shooting. Smith is convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison, providing closure to the victims' families.
Topics discussed
Intro and promotion of What the Fact
Case overview: Brothers Down in Tulsa
911 call and initial dispatch
Episode intro and sponsor read
Sponsor: Jenny Bird jewelry
Sponsor: Sleep product and Bombas
Detective Kennedy arrives at the scene
Victim identification: Keith Williams
Scene evidence: shell casings found
Detective Calhoun contacts Mary Williams
Identifying second victim via tattoo
Detective's reflection on the call
Early investigation: unknown motive
Interview with 911 caller Jamila
Jamila describes suspicious SUV
Jamila's account of the shooting
Follow-up call to victims' wives
Sponsor: Bombas socks
Sponsor: Crimes of Reddit podcast
Detective Calhoun's follow-up call
Detective's emotional reaction
New lead: witness saw suspect vehicle
Return to scene and witness interview
Detective Calhoun re-interviews Jamila
Investigation theories: hit vs robbery
Jamila's second interview with attorney
Detectives' assessment of Jamila
Detective's internal monologue
Two weeks later: new lead from Watkins
Suspect identified: Andre L. Smith
Linking Smith to Incredible Pizza shooting
Smith's girlfriend arrested and released
Vigil for Glenn Williams' family
Charges dropped against girlfriend
Sponsor: ixl learning platform
Sponsor: HomeServe repairs
Sponsor: Government That Doesn't Suck
Locating Smith's girlfriend for interview
Interview with Smith's girlfriend begins
Girlfriend confirms presence at murder
Girlfriend describes the shooting
Girlfriend claims Smith shot her
Detectives' reaction to interview
Interview with Andre Smith begins
Smith denies involvement in murder
Ballistics evidence presented to Smith
Smith refuses DNA sample
Detectives' frustration with Smith
Charges dismissed and family notified
Calling victims' families with update
Mary Williams' reflection seven months later
Episode outro and next week preview
Return to What the Fact and sponsor
What the Fact intro and history fact
Sponsor: Nissan Rogue
More from Hidden History with Dr. Harini Bhat
Listen ad-free on Castria