190. Reddit Scary Stories: The Darkest Things Hiding in Plain Sight (feat. Angela Giarratana & Morgan Absher)
Aug 27, 2026 · 1h 1m
Summary
The hosts discuss spooky stories, starting with a Reddit tale about a man unwittingly participating in a bizarre fertility ritual involving women and "masculine energy." They then analyze a chilling account of cousins terrorized by a predatory neighbor who attempted to break into their room with a box cutter. The episode concludes with a story about a woman receiving threatening messages from a hacker who possesses private, childhood photos of her.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Hungry Root meal kit service
Intro: Spooky Reddit stories and teacher support
Guests join and discuss definitions of spooky
Movie Midsummer and cult-like atmospheres
Story: Brother's bizarre blind date with women
Analysis: Fertility ritual or MLM recruitment?
Discussion: Cult tactics and saving hair traditions
Tangent: Pain tolerance and childbirth stories
Story: Creepy neighbor stalking cousins at sleepover
Discussion: The decline of sleepovers and safety
Story: Cold case kidnapping and parental denial
Nostalgia: Childhood rules and Ouija boards
Sponsors: Home sleep study and Shapermint
Story: Stalker sends private photos via KakaoTalk
Digital safety: Wi-Fi hacking and location tracking
Stories: Weird fan encounters and forced vulnerability
Sponsors: Shopify and Alma therapy platform
Story: Girlfriend's box of stolen personal items
Outro: Childhood pranks and credits
Listen ad-free on Castria