Going Rogue Going Rogue

The Fall of Skywalker III: TrIXie

May 19, 2026 · 1h 22m

Summary

Host Tansy Gartem analyzes the production of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, contrasting J.J. Abrams' fluid, Steadicam-heavy direction with George Lucas' editing-focused style. The episode explores how an unfinished script led to on-set rewrites, resulting in generic character designs and a convoluted plot. It also examines casting uncertainties, including Matt Smith’s scrapped role, and critiques the film’s narrative inconsistencies.

Topics discussed

David Lynch's departure and Richard Marquand's direction of Return of the Jedi Rise of Skywalker production start, cast styling, and Kylo Ren's mask symbolism J.J. Abrams' filmmaking style: camera movement, Steadicam, and on-set rewriting Character inconsistencies: Janna, Beaumont, Matt Smith, and Rey's generic villain look The Wayfinder plot hole, Pasaana filming logistics, and the Coruscant jump scene Filming the Death Star fight, Daisy Ridley's struggles, and Finn's sidelined arc The deleted Oracle scene, Matt Smith speculation, and the Mustafar massacre Exegol battle scale issues, Rey and Kylo's connection, and production wrap
Listen ad-free on Castria