A Haunted House in Appalachia: Hinsdale House Part 1
Summary
Hosts Macy and Natalie discuss the Dandy family’s four-year ordeal in the Hinsdale House, considered New York’s most haunted home. The episode covers the family’s move in 1970, detailing escalating paranormal events including full-body apparitions, disembodied voices, and unexplained injuries. They also explore theories about the land’s dark history, such as a potential Native American massacre or stagecoach murders, alongside the family’s sightings of UFOs and mysterious chanting.
Topics discussed
Introduction and Star Wars ad
Overview of the Hinsdale House haunting
Episode setup and tea break
EMF readings and land history theories
Native massacre rumors and stagecoach route
Historical murders and accidental deaths
Discussion on local records and Star Wars ad
The Dandy family background and move
House features and the pet menagerie
Car overheating and the bee infestation
Initial disturbances and moved items
Gunshots and the first ghost sighting
Winter hardships and physical injuries
UFO sightings and Clara's skepticism
Sponsor segment for Quince
Umbrella nights and Mary's room
Gregorian chants and children's experiences
Psychological reaction to the haunting
Flashlight encounter and entity in the woods
Beth's letter and the hanging figure
Car troubles and Mike's accident
The 16-year-old boy apparition
Exorcism, conclusion, and outro
Listen ad-free on Castria