True Lies
Kathleen Lipscomb Murder Case
Nov 5, 2026 · 20m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates the 1990 murder of Kathleen Lipscomb, a nurse in San Antonio, which remained unsolved for years despite forensic evidence. The case was eventually cracked when investigators analyzed her diary, which revealed her estranged husband, Air Force Sergeant Bill Lipscomb, had cheated on promotion exams. Forensic psychology and crime scene reconstruction exposed that the body had been staged by Bill's friend, Tony Borrello, to mimic a sex crime.
Topics discussed
Intro: Mark Bittman and Toast sponsorship
Sponsorships: Citizens Bank and Stamps.com
Sponsorship: Stamps.com
Case Introduction: The unsolved murder of Kathleen Lipscomb
Background: Kathleen's life and disappearance
Discovery of the body and initial reaction
Forensic clues: Military-style clothing roll
Investigation of Bill Lipscomb and alibi
Autopsy findings and suspect Dr. David Pearl
Dr. Pearl's relationship and other suspects
Suspect Vincent Robodeau and investigation stall
Sponsorship: Citizens Bank
Sponsorship: McDonald's
Sponsorship: Series by Marriott
Sponsorship: Stamps.com
Sponsorship: Stamps.com
Forensic timeline: Food and ant bites
Forensic analysis of red hair strands
Limitations of 1980s genetic testing
Clearing suspect Vincent Robodeau
New tip: Witness sees redheaded woman
Family suspicion and hiring private investigator
Diary clue: Name Shannon Gilbert
Investigating Shannon Gilbert and Bill's affair
Diary clue: WAPS testing and cheating
Bill's rapid promotion and Air Force investigation
Dr. McDowell joins and identifies staged scene
Realization: Bill is the killer, not just the payer
Forensic insight: Body stored in cramped space
Strategy: Multiple players and body disposal
Child's testimony: Father wasn't where he said
Revealing the alibi: Tony Borrello and the children
Lost forensic evidence and need for corroboration
Sponsorship: Citizens Bank
Sponsorship: McDonald's
Sponsorship: Toast IQ
Sponsorship: ADT
Sponsorship: ADT
Motive: Blackmail and custody battle
Threats and the decision to kill
Identifying Tony Borrello as the body dumper
Borrello's confession and the cedar chest
Forensic confirmation: Blood in the chest
Psychological tactics and Shannon Gilbert's admission
Interrogation: Bill Lipscomb's slip of the tongue
Reconstructing the night of the murder
Sequence of events: Argument and strangulation
Body disposal and the planted red hairs
Resolution: Guilty plea and sentencing
Fates of co-conspirators and case summary
Reflections on the complexity of the investigation
Sponsorship: Citizens Bank
Sponsorship: Stamps.com
Sponsorship: Pura
Sponsorship: Bowl & Branch
More from Forensic Files
Listen ad-free on Castria