"A good movie is three good scenes and no bad ones” with Billy Mernit | The Movie Racket
Summary
Host Michael Phillips and story analyst Billy Murnett examine Howard Hawks’ rule that a good film consists of "three good scenes and no bad ones." They analyze iconic moments from classics like *The Big Sleep* and *The Third Man*, alongside modern hits such as *Bridesmaids*, *Get Out*, and *Sinners*. The discussion explores how memorable scenes, strong premises, and character depth outweigh strict plot mechanics in creating lasting cinematic impact.
Topics discussed
Intro, ads, and Howard Hawks' 'three good scenes' rule
Guest Billy Murnett introduced: 30-year story analyst
Defining good vs. bad scenes and audience memory
Plot points and iconic moments: Star Wars examples
Bad scenes, test screenings, and shrinking attention spans
Howard Hawks' style: To Have and Have Not
The Third Man and Hitchcock's segmented showcases
Ads for Point.me, Solita, and Hollywood Handbook
The Big Sleep: Bogart, Bacall, and scene sensibility
The Big Sleep's eroticism and The Treasure of the Sierra Madre
Ryan Coogler's Sinners and Delroy Lindo's performance
Billy's career: Story analyst duties and studio notes
Ads for Hollywood Handbook, Solita, and Joy 101
Bridesmaids, Melissa McCarthy, and cult classics
Get Out: Premise, execution, and the teacup scene
Screenwriting collaboration and low-budget hits
Conclusion, final Hawks thoughts, and outro ads
Listen ad-free on Castria