Fantasy Football Today Fantasy Football Today

Week 6 Recap: McCarthy vs Winston, Coker vs McMillan, Jacobs Returns, & More! (10/19 Fantasy Football Podcast)

Oct 19, 2026 · 54m

Summary

This episode of Beyond the Box Score recaps Week 6, focusing on the Green Bay Packers' offensive struggles and the impact of Josh Jacobs' return on their run game. The hosts also debate whether J.J. McCarthy or Jameis Winston is the better fit for the Giants' pass catchers, analyzing McCarthy's strong arm versus his tendency to force first reads. Additionally, they discuss buy-low candidates like Tucker Kraft and evaluate the fantasy value of Jalen Coker compared to Tee Higgins.

Topics discussed

Sponsor Read: Sierra Gear Intro: Week 6 Recap and Game of the Week Preview: Josh Jacobs and Giants QB Situation Cowboys vs Packers: Score and Points Per Game Cowboys Offense: Underachievement and Dak Prescott Cowboys Passing Game: Rhythm and Scheme Issues Cowboys Defense and Health Outlook Packers Receivers: Drops and Matthew Golden Packers Offensive Line and Quick Snap Counts Jordan Love and Tucker Kraft Usage Film Breakdowns and Usage Data Updates Giants Running Back Matchup and News Notes Giants QB Decision: Winston vs McCarthy Jalen Hurts Injury and Tanner McKee Stats Giants Passing Volume and Touchdown Potential Makai Lemon and Sean McVay Injury News Giants Offensive Line Injuries Sponsor Read: Skincare Josh Jacobs: Fantasy Outlook and RB Share Packers Run Game and Jordan Love Targets Josh Jacobs Receiving Volume Projections Josh Jacobs Efficiency and Touchdown Potential Film Review: Jacobs and Strong Runs Josh Jacobs vs Chase Brown Poll Transition to Giants QB Discussion Jameis Winston vs JJ McCarthy Performance JJ McCarthy Arm Strength and Velocity Giants Receivers: Neighbors and Likely Catches JJ McCarthy Mistakes and Luck Giants QB Stats and Jameis Preference Giants Schedule and Defense Matchups Fantasy Matchup Philosophy: Game Flow Giants WRs: Nabors, Smith, and Scadaboo Devontae Smith Slot Matchups and Health Tedra McMillan Target Rate and Role McMillan vs Coker PPR Comparison McMillan Upcoming Matchups Buy Low: Michael Wilson and AJ Brown AJ Brown Health and Performance Romeo Dobbs and Pop Douglas Production Bears WR Group and Offensive Line Nico Collins Potential and Role Jalen Noel and Marvin Harrison Jr. Buys Marvin Harrison Jr. and Carnell Tate Buy Low: Jahan Dotson Jahan Dotson One-on-One Matchups Giants RBs: Tracy and Scadaboo Giants RB Schedule and Najee Harris Steelers vs Bucs: Second Half Collapse Buy Low: Travis Etienne and Jeremiah Love Jeremiah Love Schedule and Health Trade Poll: Jacobs for Love or Etienne Chase Brown and Samaj Paine Usage Host Departure and Eye Issues Caleb Williams Game Plan and Completion % Caleb Williams Targets and Play Action Luther Burden Role and Personnel Bears RBs: Irving and Warren Buy Lows Final Thoughts and Sign Off
Listen ad-free on Castria