S12 | The Boy in the Water Bonus Episode 1: What’s Happening
Nov 11, 2026 · 46m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
In this bonus episode, host Melanie Reid travels to Southland to interview Lockie Jones’s father, Paul, and his support person, Karen Maguire, regarding the status of the third police investigation. They discuss the critical failure to have Lockie examined by a forensic pathologist, which resulted in the loss of key evidence, and explore the lack of accountability within New Zealand’s coronial system. The conversation also covers the family’s consideration of exhuming Lockie’s body to seek further forensic answers.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Lowe's Veterans Day discount
Sponsor: Olive & June nail sale
Intro: Traveling to Southland to meet Lockie's family
Scenic drive through Southland farmland
Update on police reinvestigation timeline
Impact of non-forensic autopsy on the case
Missing core body temperature tests and time of death
Arrival in Gore and meeting Paul and Karen
Recap of Lockie's discovery and early reporting
Paul and Karen's amateur detective work
Police statement on lack of criminal evidence
Engaging overseas forensic experts for review
Coroner's directive for a fresh investigation
Inquest findings on Lockie's movements and death
Witness accounts and identification issues
Criticism of initial police scene investigation
Sponsor: Citizens Bank cash bonus
Interview: Who ordered the general autopsy?
Inquest testimony on coroner's initial direction
Role of the Police Form 47 in decision making
Timeline of coroner's instructions and police input
Discrepancy between forensic and general post-mortem
Police insistence that forensic exam was unnecessary
Police officer testimony on morning communications
Clarifying police view on death routine status
Mystery of how Lockie was sent to general pathologist
General pathologist's testimony at inquest
Pathologist's recollection of instructions received
Lack of records for coroner-pathologist discussion
Review of Police Form 47 details
Reference to hostile domestic situation in form
Pathologist's view on need for forensic exam
Sponsor: Citizens Bank mobile app
Sponsor: Sleep apnea treatment ad
Paul's view on the autopsy as the core issue
Legal status and powers of NZ coroners
Lack of oversight and accountability for coroners
Comparison with Australian coronial system
Criticism of police influence on coroner decisions
Debate on coroner's final decision authority
Broader systemic issues revealed by the case
Possibility of exhumation for further evidence
Discussion on police recommendations for exhumation
Lack of proof of drowning in police findings
Outcome of the third police investigation
Paul's decision to pursue exhumation
Explanation of CT scan and skeletal examination
Release of investigation file to Paul Jones
Forensic evidence of foam in fatal drowning
Outro: Subscription and credits
Sponsor: Lowe's Black Friday appliances
Sponsor: Ashby hiring platform
More from DELVE
Listen ad-free on Castria