Deep Cover Deep Cover

Episode 1: The Warrior

May 12, 2025 · 40m

Summary

Hosts Jake Halpern and Jess McHugh investigate Sarah Cavanaugh, a woman who deceived veterans and charities by fabricating a heroic military service and terminal illness. The episode details how friends initially bonded with Sarah at retreats before discovering her forged documents and lies. It sets the stage for a deep dive into her elaborate con and the betrayal of those who trusted her.

Topics discussed

Sponsors and podcast introduction Jake reads Sarah's letter and introduces the mystery Catherine Dexter's first impressions of Sarah at the Montana retreat Sarah's tragic backstory: injuries, cancer, and camaraderie The Arlington Cemetery visit and the suspicious brother discrepancy Natalie's account of the CrossFit competition and leg amputation Tom meets Sarah at the Colorado retreat and offers help Tom discovers discrepancies in Sarah's military records The investigation reveals Sarah's elaborate deception Credits and final sponsor messages

More from Deep Cover

Nikki Cheng Saelee-McCain | Gone: The Disappearances
Nov 16, 2026
Deep Cover Presents: The JFK Papers That Weren't
Oct 19, 2026
Deep Cover Presents: Switched At Birth
Oct 13, 2026
The Limits of Manifesting Success with James Forman, Jr.
Jun 29, 2026
My Oldest, Dearest Friend
Jun 22, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria