Dave tries chocolate peanut butter ice cream for the first time, reacting with intense enthusiasm while his co-host Jason, who has a peanut allergy, watches in envy. The hosts discuss a man who damaged his eyes using a massage gun, a chaotic live TV report with drunk Scottish fans, and a dentist who jokes about offering sexual services to patients. They also address a listener who accidentally entered a BDSM relationship after opening "Pandora's box" on a date.