Alleged eye drop murder. A divorce attorney on trial. Plus, criminal investigations at sea.
Sep 17, 2026 · 34m
Summary
This episode covers the murder trial of divorce attorney Gregory Moore, accused of stabbing his client Eliza Sherman, and the case of paramedic Joshua Hunsucker, charged with poisoning his wife with eye drop chemicals. Updates include the Lindsey Clancy holdout juror controversy, a wrongful death lawsuit against singer David Burke, and the decision not to seek the death penalty in the Nick Reiner case. A Coast Guard agent also explains the unique challenges of investigating crimes at sea.
Topics discussed
Sponsorships: Carvana and Opil
Show intro and episode docket overview
Joshua Hunsucker: Background and Stacy's death
Investigation: Insurance fraud and blood evidence
Arrest, charges, and defense strategy
Additional charges: Arson, kidnapping, and poisoning
Trial delay and segment conclusion
Sponsorships: Carvana, Ro, and CertiFoam
Eliza Sherman case: Background and recent arrest
Sherman murder details and surveillance evidence
Attorney's prior crimes and motive theories
Defense motions, delays, and jury selection start
Dateline Roundup introduction
Sponsorships: Ro and Angi
Lindsey Clancy: Mistrial and holdout juror controversy
Clancy case: Judge's ruling on juror safety
David Burke: Civil lawsuit against family and team
Nick Reiner: Pretrial hearing and no death penalty
Coast Guard agent on maritime crime investigations
Outro, credits, and upcoming episode preview
Listen ad-free on Castria