Dateline Originals Dateline Originals

Five Miles From Home - Ep. 3: Open Murder

Aug 21, 2026 · 35m

Summary

This episode details the investigation into the murder of teenager Mickey Costanzo, focusing on the confession of her boyfriend, Cody Patton. Detectives uncover forensic evidence linking Cody’s borrowed SUV to the crime scene, leading to his admission of killing Mickey after an argument. However, defense attorney John Olson and private investigator Bill Savage question the confession’s validity due to discrepancies with the brutal autopsy findings. The narrative highlights the town’s shock and sets the stage for uncovering deeper secrets surrounding the crime.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: Lowe's and Mint Mobile Investigation: The borrowed SUV and soil evidence Interrogation: Cody Patton's confession Aftermath: Arrest and family's disbelief Sponsors: IXL, Lowe's, and Mint Mobile Community shock and further evidence search Defense strategy: Attorney John Olson's doubts Sponsors: Lowe's, Mint Mobile, and Wayfair Memorial service and Tony Fratto's loyalty Investigator Bill Savage questions the confession Credits and Sponsor: Temperpedic
Listen ad-free on Castria