The Family Plot
Summary
Dateline NBC investigates the 2024 murder of Matt Rastelli in American Fork, Utah, where his brother-in-law Kevin was charged with killing him. The episode contrasts the conflicting narratives of the two families, highlighting evidence such as an AirTag used to track Matt, a knife found in his non-dominant hand, and the mother’s alleged coaching of her daughter during police questioning. Reporter Josh Mankowicz explores the toxic dynamics of the marriage, the mother’s history of manipulation, and the online friend who witnessed Kate’s suspicious behavior, suggesting the shooting was a stage…
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Mazda Consumer Reports Safety
Intro: The Shooting and Family Division
Crime Scene: Police Arrival and Initial Statements
Investigation Begins: Detective Norden on Scene
Detective's Perspective: Complexity of the Case
Background: Matt and Kate's Marriage and Abuse
The Escape Plan and Matt's Death
Sponsors: Wise, Row, and Certda
The Story: Self-Defense Claim and Custody
Matt's Family Reaction and Character Assessment
Kate's Behavior and Family Estrangement
Sponsors: Wise and Row
Suspicious Calls and the AirTag Discovery
Evidence: AirTag Tracking and Text Messages
Forensics: The Knife, Wrist Wound, and Cocaine
Tracy's Background and Character Testimony
Kate's Online Friends and Post-Shooting Behavior
Arrests and Tarolyn's Reaction
Recorded Calls Contradicting the Story
Kevin's Trial, Verdict, and Sentencing
Tracy's Trial and Guilty Verdict
Aftermath: Family Fallout and Grief
Listen ad-free on Castria