Talking Dateline: The Man Who Loved Christmas
Summary
Dateline producers Allison Orr and Kim Krawitz discuss the case of Harold Allen, a man in southern Indiana murdered by his wife Marcia and daughter Ashley. The investigation was triggered by a burglary at the widow’s home, where a suspect’s body camera footage revealed the plot to poison Harold with ethylene glycol. The hosts analyze the digital evidence, including thousands of texts between the conspirators, and reflect on the close-knit family dynamics of the victim’s surviving brothers.
Topics discussed
Intro and Capital One Bank Guy ad
Welcome and introduction of producers
Summary of Harold Allen's sudden death
The burglary that revealed the murder plot
The close bond of the Allen brothers
Harold's struggle with love and meeting Marcia
Family suspicions about Marcia and the reunion
Red flags: Marcia's reaction and grief book
Sponsorship breaks: Progressive, Mint, Granger
How the cat cameras caught the burglar
Stephen White's bizarre body cam interview
Clip: Stephen White's phone call and character
Digital evidence: 24,000 text messages
Poisons used and the mother-daughter split
Family reaction to Marcia's suicide
Sponsorship breaks: South Dakota, Mazda, SNHU
Social media Q&A with Jess Cornig
Outro and Dateline season premiere promo
Energy Transfer sponsorship
Listen ad-free on Castria